|
PART IX
Breach of International Trust
Liability for breach of trust
27. (1) Subject to the provisions of this Act
and to the terms of an international trust a trustee who commits or concurs in
a breach of an international trust is liable for
(a) any loss or depreciation in value of
the property of the international trust resulting from the breach; and
(b) any profit which would have accrued
to the international trust had there been no breach.
(2) A trustee shall not set-off a profit
accruing from one breach of an international trust against a loss or
depreciation in value resulting from another breach of an international
trust.
(3) A trustee is not liable for a breach of an
international trust, committed by another person prior to his or her
appointment or for a breach of an international trust committed by a co-trustee
unless
(a) the trustee becomes or ought to have
become aware of the breach; and
(b) the trustee actively conceals the
breach, or fails within a reasonable time to take proper steps to protect or
restore the trust property or to prevent the breach.
(4) Where trustees are liable for a breach of
an international trust, they are liable jointly or severally.
(5) A trustee who becomes aware of a breach of
an international trust shall take all reasonable steps to have the breach
remedied.
(6) Nothing in the terms of an international
trust shall relieve a trustee of liability for a breach of the international
trust arising from, the trustee's own fraud, self dealing or willful
misconduct.
[Back to the
top]
Constructive trusts
28. (1) A person who derives a profit or
obtains trust property as a result of a breach of an international trust shall
be deemed to be a trustee of such profit or trust property unless that person
derives or obtains in it good faith and without actual, constructive or implied
notice of the breach of trust.
(2) A person who becomes a trustee by virtue of
subsection (1) shall deliver up the profit or trust property to the person
properly entitled to it.
(3) This section does not exclude any other
circumstance in which a constructive trust may arise.
[Back to the
top]
Tracing
trust property
29. Without prejudice to the personal liability
of a trustee, trust property which has been changed or dealt with through a
breach of the international trust or any property into which the trust property
has been converted may be traced, followed and recovered unless
(a) it is no longer identifiable;
or
(b) it is in the hands of a good faith
purchaser for value without actual constructive or implied notice of the breach
of the international trust.
[Back to the
top]
Beneficiary may relieve or indemnify trustee
30. (1) A beneficiary may relieve a trustee of
liability to the beneficiary for a breach of an international trust or may
indemnify a trustee against liability for a breach of the international
trust.
(2) Subsection (1) does not apply if the
beneficiary
(a) is a minor or a person under legal
disability;
(b) does not have full knowledge of all
material facts; or
(c) is improperly induced by the trustee
to act under subsection (1).
[Back to the
top]
Power to relieve trustee from personal liability
31. The Court may relieve a trustee wholly or
partly of liability for a breach of an international trust where it appears to
the Court that the trustee has acted honestly and reasonably and ought fairly
to be excused for the breach of international trust or for omitting to obtain
the direction of the Court in the matter in which the breach arose.
[Back to the
top]
PART X
Proper Law and Effect of Foreign
Law
Proper law
of trust
32. (1) Subject to any express provisions in
the trust instrument, or any intention of the settlor derived from the trust
instrument, the proper law applicable to an international trust shall be as in
this Act.
(2) Subject to subsection (1), the terms of an international trust may provide
(a) for the severable aspects of the
international trust, particularly aspects relating to the administration of the
international trust, to be governed by a different law from the proper law of
the international trust; and
(b) for the law governing a severable
aspect of the international trust to be changed from the law in force in Saint
Lucia to the law of another jurisdiction and vice versa.
(3) A change in the proper law of an
international trust shall not affect the legality or validity of the
international trust or render any person liable for anything done before the
change unless the liability would result under both the old and the new proper
law of the international trust.
[Back to the
top]
Change of
proper law
33. (1) Where the proper law of an
international trust or the law governing the severable aspects of an
international trust is changed from the law in force in Saint Lucia to the law
of another jurisdiction (in this section referred to as the "new
law") no provision of the law in force in Saint Lucia shall operate to
render void, invalid or unlawful any function conferred on the trustee under
the new law.
(2) Where the proper law of an international
trust or the law governing the severable aspects of a trust is changed from the
law of another jurisdiction (in this section referred to as the "old
law") to the law in force in Saint Lucia, no provision of the old law
shall operate to render the trust void, invalid or unlawful or to render void,
invalid or unlawful any functions conferred on the trustee under the law in
force in Saint Lucia.
[Back to the
top]
Exclusion of foreign laws and rights arising
thereunder
34. An
international trust governed by this Act or a disposition of property to be
held upon the international trust, shall not be varied, declared void,
voidable, liable to be set aside or defective in any manner, and the capacity
of any settlor is not to be questioned by reason that
(a) the laws of any foreign jurisdiction
prohibit or do not recognise the concept of an international trust either in
part or in whole;
(b) the international trust or
disposition avoids or defeats rights, claims or interests conferred by the law
of the foreign jurisdiction upon any person, or contravenes any law, rule,
judicial or administrative order or action intended to recognise, protect
enforce or give effect to any such rights, claims or interests;
(c) the international trust creates
rights in property that are contrary to other laws relating to the personal or
proprietary effects of marriage or the succession rights testate and intestate,
of any person;
(d) the law in force in Saint Lucia or
the provisions of this Act are inconsistent with a law of a foreign
jurisdiction.
[Back to the
top]
PART XI
Powers of the Court, Proceedings and
Limitations
Jurisdiction of the court
35. (1) The Court has jurisdiction in respect
of any matter concerning the international trust.
(2) On the application of a trustee, a
beneficiary, a settlor or his or her personal representatives, a protector, or
with the leave of the Court, any other person, the Court may
(a) make an order in respect of
(i) the execution, administration or
enforcement of an international trust;
(ii) a trustee, including an order as to the
exercise of any power by a trustee, the appointment, remuneration or conduct of
a trustee, the keeping or submission of accounts, the making of payments,
whether into Court or otherwise;
(iii) a protector, including an order
appointing a protector;
(iv) a beneficiary, or any person connected
with an international trust;
(v) any trust property, including an order as
to the vesting, preservation, application, surrender or recovery
thereof;
(b) make a declaration as to the
validity or enforceability of an international trust;
(c) direct the registered trustee to
distribute, or not to distribute the trust property;
(d) make such order in respect of the
termination of the international trust and the distribution of the property as
it thinks fit;
(e) rescind or vary an order or
declaration under this Act, or make a new or further order or
declaration.
(3) Where the Court appoints or removes a
registered trustee under this section
(a) it may impose such requirements and
conditions as it thinks fit, including provisions as to remuneration and
requirements or conditions as to the vesting of trust property;
(b) subject to the Court's order a
trustee appointed by the Court has the same functions and may act in all
respects, as if he or she had been originally appointed a trustee.
(4) If a person does not comply with an order
of the Court under theis Act requiring him or her to do any thing, the Court
may, on such terms and conditions as it thinks fit, order that the thing be
done by another person, nominated for the purpose by the Court, at the expense
of the person in default or otherwise, as the Court directs and a thing so done
has effect in all respects as if done by the person in default.
[Back to the
top]
Court's determination of validity
36. (1) The Court may declare an international
trust to be invalid if
(a) the international trust was
established under duress or undue influence, or by mistake or
misrepresentation;
(b) subject to section 25, the terms of
the international trust are so uncertain that performance of such terms is
rendered impossible or impractical; or
(c) subject to section 32, the settlor
was, at the time of the disposition leading to the creation of the
international trust, incapable under the law in force in Saint Lucia of
creating an international trust.
(2) Where an international trust is created for
two or more purposes of which some are lawful and others are not, or where some
of the terms of the international trust are lawful and others are not
(a) if those purposes cannot be
separated, or the terms cannot be separated, the international trust is
invalid; or
(b) if those purposes or terms can be
separated, the Court may declare that the international trust is valid as to
the terms which are valid and the purposes which are lawful.
(3) Where an international trust is partially
invalid, the Court may declare what property is to be held subject to the
international trust.
(4) Property that is transferred by a settlor
to an international trust which is invalid, shall, subject to any order of the
Court, be held by the trustee in trust for the settlor absolutely or, if the
settlor is dead, as if the property had formed part of the settlor's estate at
death.
(5) Notwithstanding section 32, in determining
the existence and validity of an international trust registered under this Act,
the Court shall apply
(a) the provisions of this Act;
(b) any other law in force in Saint
Lucia; and
(c) any other law which may be applied
if to do so would validate the trust as an international trust.
[Back to the
top]
Saving of certain rights
37. In the event that an international trust
might be declared invalid pursuant to this Act, if the Court is satisfied that
a beneficiary has not acted in bad faith
(a) the beneficiary shall have a first
and paramount charge over the trust property in an amount equal to the entire
costs properly incurred by the beneficiary in the defense of this action or
proceedings and not merely such costs as might otherwise be allowed by the
Court; and
(b) the international trust shall be
declared invalid subject to the payment of proper fees, costs, pre-existing
rights, claims and interests of such beneficiary.
[Back to the
top]
Extent of invalidity for creditors
38. If an
international trust or disposition thereto is declared invalid under the
provisions of this Part or Part XII, the international trust or the disposition
shall be invalid only to the extent necessary to satisfy the obligations of the
creditor at whose instance the international trust or disposition was declared
invalid together with such costs as the Court may allow pursuant to the
relevant Part.
[Back to the
top]
Foreign judgements not enforceable
39. Notwithstanding the provision of any
treaty, convention, statute, or rule of law or equity to the contrary, a
proceeding for or in relation to the enforcement or recognition of a judgement
or order obtained in a jurisdiction other than Saint Lucia against
(a) an international trust;
(b) a settlor, trustee, protector or
beneficiary of an international trust;
(c) a person appointed or instructed in
accordance with the express or implied provisions of an instrument or
disposition to exercise a function, or undertake an act, matter or thing in
connection with an international trust on the property of the international
trust; or
(d) the property of an international
trust, a trustee, a protector or a beneficiary of the international
trust;
shall not be entertained by any court if that
judgement or order is based in whole or in part, upon the application of any
law or interpretation of law that is inconsistent with the provisions of this
Act or relates to a matter that is governed by the law in force in Saint
Lucia;
[Back to the
top]
Application for directions
40. A trustee may apply to the Court for
directions as to how that trustee should or might act in any of the affairs of
the international trust, and the Court may make such order as it thinks
fit.
[Back to the
top]
Payment of
costs
41. The Court may order the cost and expenses
of and expenses of and incidental to an application to the Court under this Act
be paid from the property of the international trust or in such manner and by
such persons as it thinks fit.
[Back to the
top]
Limitation on commencement of proceedings
42. (1) An action or proceeding
(a) to set aside the creation or
settlement of an international trust,
(b) to set aside any disposition to or
by any international trust
shall not be commenced unless the action or
proceeding is commenced in the Court before the expiration of two years from
the date of the creation of the international trust which is sought to be set
aside or the date of the disposition to or by the international trust that is
sought to be set aside.
(2) An action or proceedings shall not be
commenced by any person claiming to have or to have had an interest in property
before that property was settled upon or disposed to or by an international
trust and seeking to derive a legal or equitable interest in that property
unless
(a) the person can establish the nature
and extent of the interest and that the interest existed a the time of the
relevant disposition or of the creation of the international trust; and
(b) the action or proceeding is
commenced in the Court before the expiration of two years from the date that
the property was settled upon or disposed to or by the international
trust.
(3) No action or proceeding to which
subsections (1) or (2) or to which Part XII applies whether substantive or
interlocutory in nature ,shall be determined and no order shall be made or
granted by the Court including any injunction that shall have effect of
preventing the exercise of or restoring to a person any rights, duties,
obligations or powers, or preserving the exercise of or restoring to a person
any rights, duties, obligations or powers, or preserving, granting custody or,
detaining or inspecting any property, unless the applicant shall first satisfy
the Court by affidavit that
(a) the action or proceedings has been
commenced in accordance with subsections (1) or (2);
(b) where the action or proceeding shall
allege fraud or be founded upon some other action or proceeding alleging fraud,
that the determination or order sought would not be contrary to the provisions
of Part XII of this Act; and
(c) that the requirements of section 43
have been fulfilled.
(4) An affidavit required to be filed pursuant
to subsection (3) shall be made by the person on whose behalf the action or
proceeding is brought or, in the case of a body corporate, an officer thereof,
and the person or officer shall depose as to
(a) the circumstances of the cause of
action in respect of which the action or proceedings are brought;
(b) the date upon which the cause of
action shall have accrued;
(c) the date upon which the property, in
respect of which the action or proceeding is brought, was settled on, or
disposed of by, the international trust; and
(d) whether an action or proceeding has
been commenced in any jurisdiction in respect of the cause of action or the
international trust generally, and, if so, the date upon which that action or
proceeding was commenced, the nature of the proceeding and in which
jurisdiction it is pending.
(5) This section shall apply to every
interntaional trust expressed to be governed by the law in force in Saint Lucia
and, in the event that a trust shall be registered as an international trust
and shall change the law by which it shall be governed to that of Saint Lucia
then every proceeding after that date of registration by a person claiming to
be interested in, or to be prejudiced by, the settlement of property upon the
trust, or disposition of property to the trust before registration, shall be
commenced subject to subsections (1) and (2) and every determination and order
shall be made subject to subsection (3) as if upon the date that such
settlement or disposition was made the trust was an international trust
governed by the law in force in Saint Lucia.
[Back to the
top]
Security
for costs
43. A creditor before bringing any action or
proceeding against an international trust or trust property or with respect or
within respect to any disposition by or to an international trust or any other
matter governed by this Act shall first deposit with the Court a cash sum of
twenty-five thousand United States dollars, or such greater amount as may be
ordered by the Court, securing the payment of all costs as may become payable
by the creditor in the event of the creditor not succeeding in the action or
proceeding against the trust property or the international trust or in respect
of the relevant disposition.
[Back to the
top]
|